Written by Jasdeep Sandhu, JD Candidate 2027
Note: The information below is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Its application will depend on the circumstances of each situation.
Introduction
Share options are the most common method by which growth companies grant equity to talent.[1] More than 90% of Silicon Valley technology firms and 88% of the top 50 TSX Venture Growth companies in 2024 used share options.[2]
This blog provides a brief overview of stock options, followed by a discussion of some of their advantages and disadvantages that Canadian growth companies may wish to consider.
What are Stock Options?
Stock options grant individuals the right to purchase common shares at a fixed exercise price within a specified period.[3] Therefore, if the stock price rises and the individual is able to exercise their option, they may purchase the common shares at the lower, previously established exercise price.[4] Usually, growth companies vest stock options, gradually granting employees the right to exercise them once they have been working with the company for a specific time (e.g. 2 years) or reach set performance targets.[5]
Five Advantages of Stock Options
1. Talent Retention
Share options are useful for talent retention. As stated earlier, stock options typically use vesting schedules that grant individuals the right to exercise options over time, as they continue working for the company or meet specified performance goals.[6] However, if the employee leaves the company early, they forfeit their unexercised options.[7] This provides an incentive for the employee to remain with the company. It should be noted, however, that under Canadian employment law, unless there was express, clear contractual language stating share options terminate on the date of notice, they will continue to vest throughout the appropriate notice period after termination.[8] This exception has been applied narrowly, as courts tend to view employee claims more sympathetically.[9]
2. No Immediate Tax Concerns
Under Section 7 of the Canadian Income Tax Act, granting stock options is not a taxable event.[10] Unlike non-CCPC Share Grants, which require the employee to pay tax immediately, the employee would not need to pay tax until the options are at least exercised.[11]
3. Stability of Governance
Until exercised, stock options confer neither voting rights nor shareholder status.[12] This offers a useful way to grant equity incentives to key talent the company seeks to retain while preserving its corporate governance structure and voting authority.[13] Instead, it allows changes to corporate governance structures to happen more gradually as shares vest and subsequently, employees exercise their options.
4. Preferential Tax Treatment for Canadian-Controlled Private Corporations (CCPCs)
Share options carry preferential tax treatment if your startup qualifies as a Canadian-Controlled Private Corporation (CCPC).[14] Section 7(1.1) of the Income Tax Act states that tax is deferred to the tax year in which the underlying shares are sold.[15] This can be advantageous because it provides sufficient liquidity to pay the tax, unlike non-CCPC Share Grants where employees are taxed immediately yet may be unable to sell the shares (e.g. contract prohibitions or blackout periods post-IPO) or must sell them at a price insufficient to cover the tax liability.[16]
5. Greater Upside for Employees
Stock options provide employees with greater potential for equity appreciation. Startups are more likely to issue a larger volume of stock options than share grants.[17] A share grant has financial value even if the company's value stagnates and it receives little or no payment for issuing grants.[18] In comparison, stock options are only valuable if the company grows, allowing startups to issue more options.[19]
Five Stock Option Disadvantages
1. No Preferential Tax Treatment for Non-CCPCs
Non-CCPCs are not entitled to defer taxes until the shares are sold.[20] Instead, exercising the option triggers immediate employment income tax, regardless of whether the shares can be sold or how much they are selling for.[21] This is a major drawback. If the shares are illiquid (e.g. contractual reasons, blackout periods post-IPO, etc.), employees must pay taxes without any cash from a sale.[22] This also creates potential liability for the growth company, as employers are required to withhold and remit income taxes on exercised options.[23] This can be problematic because growth companies don’t have massive cash reserves to pay large amounts of income tax when employees exercise stock options.[24]
2. Ineligibility for Major Tax Exemptions
Stock options don’t allow employees to easily qualify for major tax exemptions that share grants may.[25] Stock options make it challenging for employees to apply for the Lifetime Capital Gains Exemption (exempt up to $1.275 million from selling shares from capital gains tax) and the Canadian Entrepreneurs’ Incentive (reduced inclusion rate of 33.33% on up to $2 million in capital gains).[26] Both of these exemptions impose a requirement that the employee actually hold common shares for a certain period of time before selling.[27]
3. Incentive Disappears if Stock Price Dips Below Original Strike Price
Options lose economic value when the current share price falls below the original strike price.[28] If a growth company’s valuation falls to the point where its options are worth less than they were when awarded, the options become less effective at retaining talent and incentivizing performance.[29] This can be challenging to address, as growth companies cannot simply lower strike prices; investors who have already incurred losses may view such a move as an attempt to evade accountability.[30]
4. Accounting Requirements and Overstatement of Expenses
Current accounting standards require the fair value of the stock options on the grant date to be recognized as expenses in financial statements.[31] It can either be spread over a vesting period, or, if the options vest immediately, it will be recorded only in the statements on the grant date.[32] Under IFRS, this treatment may overstate expenses because valuation models such as the Black-Scholes model, which are used to calculate fair value, are not well equipped to value options issued by startups or growth companies.[33] They may fail to account for restrictions on options, including extended vesting periods, early exercise by employees, and post-IPO blackout periods, all of which may reduce their value.[34] Consequently, option-related expenses reported in financial statements are drastically overstated, reducing reported earnings.[35] This can harm startups and growth companies that want to attract investors who require evidence of strong margins.[36]
5. Encouragement of Risky Behaviours
Lastly, stock options can make managers take on too much risk.[37] Managers at a growth company may be incentivized to engage in risky behavior to boost short-term share prices and maximize their personal gains, even if doing so means neglecting the company's future.[38]
Conclusion
Stock options have many benefits. Stock options provide tax deferrals or preferential tax rates for CCPCs.[39] They provide growth companies with significant leverage to retain talent through long term vesting schedules.[40] Options also allow the company to retain control over governance, as they do not grant voting rights.[41]
On the other hand, stock options also have drawbacks. If the company is not a CCPC, tax is due as soon as an employee exercises an option, potentially creating liabilities for both the employee and the employer, which must remit employment taxes.[42] Options become disincentivizing if the share price falls below the exercise price.[43] They can also make the company appear less profitable than it is, since accounting standards require options to be treated as expenses and current accounting formulas may value them above their actual worth.[44] Lastly, they can encourage managerial powers to take excessive risks to increase the value of their options.[45]
Endnotes
[1] Bryce C Tingle KC, Start-Up and Growth Companies in Canada: A Guide to Legal and Business Practice, 4th ed (Toronto: LexisNexis Canada, 2026) at 158 [Tingle].
[2] Ibid at 152; Government of Canada, “Employee security (stock) options” (March 26, 2026) online: https://www.canada.ca/en/revenue-agency/services/tax/businesses/topics/payroll/benefits-allowances/security-options.html [Government of Canada].
[3] Tingle, supra note 1 at 159-160.
[4] Tingle, supra note 1 at 159-160.
[5] Tingle, supra note 1 at 159-161.
[6] Tingle, supra note 1 at 159-161.
[7] Tingle, supra note 1 at 161.
[8] Tingle, supra note 1 at 161-162.
[9] Tingle, supra note 1 at 162.
[10] Tingle, supra note 1 at 167; Government of Canada, supra note 2.
[11] Tingle, supra note 1 at 154-155 and 169.
[12] Tingle, supra note 1 at 166.
[13] Tingle, supra note 1 at 166.
[14] Tingle, supra note 1 at 168.
[15] Tingle, supra note 1 at 168; Income Tax Act, RSC 1985, c 1 (5th Supp), s 7(1.1).
[16] Tingle, supra note 1 at 168.
[17] Tingle, supra note 1 at 166.
[18] Tingle, supra note 1 at 166.
[19] Tingle, supra note 1 at 166.
[20] Tingle, supra note 1 at 169.
[21] Tingle, supra note 1 at 169.
[22] Tingle, supra note 1 at 163-164 and 169.
[23] Tingle, supra note 1 at 169.
[24] Tingle, supra note 1 at 169.
[25] Tingle, supra note 1 at 154.
[26] Tingle, supra note 1 at 154; Turbotax Canada, “Claiming the Lifetime Capital Gains Exemption (LCGE)” (August 10, 2026) online: https://turbotax.intuit.ca/tips/claiming-the-capital-gains-exemption-376?srsltid=AYCX9vLzBP9iBCV3SFBdY1uivVKWMVxskGPAjkaw4ejSy-kR_rA4TSA6 [Turbotax].
[27] Tingle, supra note 1 at 154.
[28] Tingle, supra note 1 at 173.
[29] Tingle, supra note 1 at 173.
[30] Tingle, supra note 1 at 173-174.
[31] Tingle, supra note 1 at 162.
[32] Tingle, supra note 1 at 162.
[33] Tingle, supra note 1 at 163-164.
[34] Tingle, supra note 1 at 163-164.
[35] Tingle, supra note 1 at 164.
[36] Carsten Berrar, Florian Späth & Heiko Blaut, “Introduction” in Venture Capital 2025 (2025) at 8, online (e-book): <gpg-pdf.chambers.com/view/998044102/9>.
[37] Tingle, supra note 1 at 165.
[38] Tingle, supra note 1 at 165.
[39] Tingle, supra note 1 at 154-155 and 168-169; Income Tax Act, RSC 1985, c 1 (5th Supp), s 7(1.1).
[40] Tingle, supra note 1 at 159-161.
[41] Tingle, supra note 1 at 166.
[42] Tingle, supra note 1 at 169.
[43] Tingle, supra note 1 at 173.
[44] Tingle, supra note 1 at 164.
[45] Tingle, supra note 1 at 165.